The Red Apple v The Janissary Tree

Feels good to be done with The Red Apple! I thought that the colloquiom went well. It was interesting to hear how my classmates interpreted the book. I have a love/hate relationship with The Red Apple. The historical facts were easy to digest because the writing was simple. It was an undoubtedly easy read (which was convenient because I had a lot of homework!). I engulfed it quickly and without much thought. I definitely enjoyed the book, I just have a few qualms with it. The story itself was weak and felt rushed. I believe Levitan tried to comprise a poingnant story enriched with history... but fell a little short. I still think Ibraham should have died defending Constantinople!
I started reading The Janissary Tree. I am on chapter five or six and it is already apparent that the writing is superior to The Red Apple. Jason Goodwin's writing is more creative and captivating. I was quickly drawn into the story and am excited for more of the mystery to unfold! I thought that The Janissary Tree was just going to be another account of a Janissary's life. I was pleasantly surprised to find that it is set in the 19th century - well after the Janissaries fall from grace. Jason Goodwin's novel is also not going to be such an easy read. His writing is more advanced and I have had to look up a few words and historical events. Perhaps towards the end of the novel I will be longing for the simplicity of The Red Apple.